Advertisement
 
 

How Often Should You Mail Prospects?

February 24, 2011 by Ivan Levison
1
One of my favorite quotes comes from John D. Rockefeller. It's on my wall and reminds me to keep planning my work and working my plan.

Rockefeller wrote: "I do not think there is any quality so essential to success of any kind as the quality of perseverance. It overcomes almost anything, even nature."

Over the years, successful direct mailers have learned this lesson well. They know that they can't mail just once and pray for great results. They have to create multiple-mailings that make money over time.

A perfect example: magazine subscription campaigns. As you know from personal experience, these folks just never quit.

It seems as if the day you subscribe, the subscription renewal campaign begins.

Never mind that they're seemingly decimating forests in the process ... they go on and on, begging, hounding, cajoling, until the 86th letter that says, "OK We give up. You'll never hear from us again." (At which point, of course, a lot of the renewals flow in!)

Now, I'm not suggesting that you go to extremes (the way the magazine publishers do), but for goodness sakes, don't throw in the towel after you mail just once!

Why don't companies keep those cards and letters coming? Because printing costs are high and postage these days is murder. But that shouldn't stop you from mailing aggressively if you've got a well-targeted list and a compelling offer.

OK. So you've bought into the idea of mailing prospects or customers more than once. How should you go about handling your remailing efforts? Here are just four ideas for you to consider:

1. Remail the original package to the same target audience.
There's no reason why you can't do this. Timing is everything. You never know when your mailing will catch prospects just when they need your product or service. A simple, cost-effective remailing is well worth trying.

2. If you have the time energy, and resources, you can send a campaign of new letters to non-responders.
Each letter can stress a unique product or service benefit. The theory is, if one approach doesn't work, you go back to the prospect with a different pitch. Again, this is a very reasonable way to go.

3. If your offer is good for a limited time only, be sure to play that up.
In your final letter you can say things like:
 
1

MORE ON DIRECT MAIL >>

FROM THE BOOKSTORE

Available as a PDF<BR><BR>A guide to the science of direct response testing today, including best practices, power tests, small vs. large test, analyzing results, testing mistakes, new tricks and more.<BR> <BR>Direct marketing — regardless of the channel — is that unique combination of art and science. Direct marketing strategists are constantly striving for better response rates, open rates, conversions, cost-per-order, and life-time value. <BR><BR>And what is the tool that these strategists turn to again and again? That’s right! It’s testing. <BR><BR>In direct marketing, there are plenty of elements to test — from subject lines, premiums, envelope sizes, list selects, pricing, the placement of the shopping cart on the web page ... the choices seem endless. <BR><I><BR>Secrets of Direct Marketing Testing </I>is your personal BRAIN TRUST of testing strategies that you can start to put to use today. <BR><BR>In this guide, you’ll find everything you need to learn — the why, what, when and how-to of testing. From testing structure to basic principles, and from test ideas to mistakes to avoid, you’ll get a crash course in coding, tracking, reading and applying test results. <BR><BR>You’ll learn about: <BR>• Simple copy tests that drive response <BR>• Fine-tuning your offer <BR>• Web and Email testing <BR>• Offer tests <BR>• How to make sure you’re getting reliable results <BR>• Retesting and rolling out your findings <BR>• Plus the Rules that you should test now — or ignore at your own peril! <BR><BR>Are you are searching for ways to raise response, save on your promotion costs, drive down your cost-per-order and extend the lifetime value of your customers? The DirectMarketingIQ and Target Marketing editorial teams have been researching, writing and collecting expert advice from industry leaders about the how-tos of testing for years. <BR><BR>We’ve compiled this information and made it easy for you to find all in one place with our easy-to-read report – <EM>Secrets of Direct Marketing Testing</EM>. Secrets of Direct Marketing Testing

Available as a PDF

A guide to the science of direct response testing today, including best practices, power tests, small vs. large test, analyzing results, testing mistakes, new tricks and more.

Direct marketing — regardless of the channel — is that unique combination of art and science. Direct marketing strategists are constantly striving



...

ORDER NOW

Available as a PDF<BR><BR>Your everything-you-need-to-know guide to personalized URLs, including: <B>Best Practices </B>on why they work, campaign strategy, multichannel creative, analytics, and <B>10 Case Studies.<BR></B><BR>A New Best Practices and Case Studies report from DirectMarketingIQ.<BR> <BR>Do you want a higher response rate? Do you want to make a bigger profit? Do you want to engage your customers and continue the conversation? Then ... you need to know about PURLs and how they can achieve all the above and more! <BR><BR>With <EM>PURLs for Profit </EM>you'll have your personal roadmap that will show you how to successfully implement and profit from PURLs. This definitive special report takes you step-by-step on how to integrate PURLs into your marketing mix — email, direct mail, landing pages and social media — for an enhanced user experience so that prospects can make more informed purchasing decisions faster. <BR><BR>Here are just a few of the important takeaways you'll learn:<BR>
<UL>
<LI>Why PURLs work 
<LI>How PURLs connect the dots between direct mail, email, social media and the web 
<LI>What you should test and why 
<LI>What campaigns benefit most from PURLs 
<LI>How to create a relevant campaign 
<LI>Privacy and PURLs 
<LI>What steps should you take 
<LI>How to measure your ROI 
<LI>Maintain the magic by maximizing the message, the creative and the list! 
<LI>The importance of tracking and continuing the conversation 
<LI>Where social media fits into the mix </LI></UL>
<P>In addition, you'll see actual case studies where PURLs have made a big difference in a variety of marketing efforts. <BR><BR>Here's a list of the types of companies and organizations that are featured in this informative special report: </P>
<UL>
<LI>Financial Services 
<LI>Higher Education 
<LI>Publishing 
<LI>Nonprofit 
<LI>Retail 
<LI>Technology 
<LI>Seminar/Conference 
<LI>Quick-Service Restaurant</LI></UL>
<P>Download your copy of <EM>PURLs for Profit</EM> today!</P> PURLs for Profit

Available as a PDF

Your everything-you-need-to-know guide to personalized URLs, including: Best Practices on why they work, campaign strategy, multichannel creative, analytics, and 10 Case Studies.

A New Best Practices and Case Studies report from DirectMarketingIQ.

Do you want a higher response rate? Do you want to make a bigger profit? Do you





...

ORDER NOW

 

COMMENTS

Click here to leave a comment...
Comment *
Most Recent Comments:
Cynthia Clotzman - Posted on February 25, 2011
Hello-
I was fortunate enough to be able to conduct a long term mailing frequency test to our house file some years ago. We had about 5 tiers of customers that were mailed at different frequencies depending on where their breakeven point was, and we were concerned that we were overmailing the top end of the file. The test approach was as follows:

1. Control: normal frequency
2. Test 1: Mail each tier as if one tier up (added a few test tiers at the top)
3. Test 2: Mail each tier as if one tier down (bottom tier received fewer mailings, but incorporated some of the components into the remaining mailings instead of deleting them altogether)

There were many learnings, but the main one is that even if your gut tells you that you are are overmailing the top customers, you probably are not and they may be able to support even more mailings and bring you LOTS more profit. Don't underestimate how much your best customers love you!


Click here to view archived comments...
Archived Comments:
Cynthia Clotzman - Posted on February 25, 2011
Hello-
I was fortunate enough to be able to conduct a long term mailing frequency test to our house file some years ago. We had about 5 tiers of customers that were mailed at different frequencies depending on where their breakeven point was, and we were concerned that we were overmailing the top end of the file. The test approach was as follows:

1. Control: normal frequency
2. Test 1: Mail each tier as if one tier up (added a few test tiers at the top)
3. Test 2: Mail each tier as if one tier down (bottom tier received fewer mailings, but incorporated some of the components into the remaining mailings instead of deleting them altogether)

There were many learnings, but the main one is that even if your gut tells you that you are are overmailing the top customers, you probably are not and they may be able to support even more mailings and bring you LOTS more profit. Don't underestimate how much your best customers love you!