Advertisement
 
 

Direct Mail: Dead or Dead On?

April 8, 2010 By Pat Friesen
6
Get the Flash Player to see this rotator.
 

Direct mail is still officially and personally delivered ... for less than a Starbuck's cup of coffee. While there's plenty of reason to be critical of the USPS, it's still a person in uniform — not a computer — who hand-delivers your mail. He or she is a "regular" in the neighborhood or office. All this carries an unspoken aura of importance.

Direct mail is virus-free. It has never made a computer crash. Need I say more?

Have you noticed there's been an increase in direct mail from restaurants? Why? They've discovered it's the cost-effective way to saturate a geographic area or radius with an appropriately relevant message and put an offer into the hands of a new customer.

Direct mail is still perceived as being private and less risky when providing credit card and other personal information.

Direct mail is personal. In an informal focus group of attendees at a direct marketing (not direct mail) workshop, I asked how many preferred receiving birthday and holiday cards by mail versus email. 100 percent said traditional mail. Now true, this was not a statistically reliable sample. But what caught my attention was the average age of 20-something. Done right, it's still hard to beat the personal appeal of traditional mail.

Direct mail databases remain a powerful prospecting tool. They allow you to target prospects you otherwise can't reach because of opt-in rules and do not call lists.

Another good reason to use direct mail is to influence sales through other channels. Think about what influences your visits to retail stores and Web sites. Often it's a catalog or postcard. Just because customers aren't mailing reply cards or order forms doesn't mean direct mail isn't working.

Last but not least, don't stick your head in the mud. Do become knowledgeable about social, mobile and other non-direct mail media. Don't use only direct mail because that's what you've always done. Become informed so you can make balanced decisions about what's right for your organization and more importantly, your customer. 

Pat Friesen is a copywriter/creative strategist who writes for direct mail, email, blogs, catalogs, the Web and other direct marketing media. She's also a sought-after copy coach, workshop presenter and columnist for Target Marketing magazine. Contact Pat at 913-341-1211 or Pat@PatFriesen.com.
 
 

Companies Mentioned:

6

MORE ON DIRECT MAIL >>

FROM THE BOOKSTORE

Available as a PDF<BR><BR>A guide to the science of direct response testing today, including best practices, power tests, small vs. large test, analyzing results, testing mistakes, new tricks and more.<BR> <BR>Direct marketing — regardless of the channel — is that unique combination of art and science. Direct marketing strategists are constantly striving for better response rates, open rates, conversions, cost-per-order, and life-time value. <BR><BR>And what is the tool that these strategists turn to again and again? That’s right! It’s testing. <BR><BR>In direct marketing, there are plenty of elements to test — from subject lines, premiums, envelope sizes, list selects, pricing, the placement of the shopping cart on the web page ... the choices seem endless. <BR><I><BR>Secrets of Direct Marketing Testing </I>is your personal BRAIN TRUST of testing strategies that you can start to put to use today. <BR><BR>In this guide, you’ll find everything you need to learn — the why, what, when and how-to of testing. From testing structure to basic principles, and from test ideas to mistakes to avoid, you’ll get a crash course in coding, tracking, reading and applying test results. <BR><BR>You’ll learn about: <BR>• Simple copy tests that drive response <BR>• Fine-tuning your offer <BR>• Web and Email testing <BR>• Offer tests <BR>• How to make sure you’re getting reliable results <BR>• Retesting and rolling out your findings <BR>• Plus the Rules that you should test now — or ignore at your own peril! <BR><BR>Are you are searching for ways to raise response, save on your promotion costs, drive down your cost-per-order and extend the lifetime value of your customers? The DirectMarketingIQ and Target Marketing editorial teams have been researching, writing and collecting expert advice from industry leaders about the how-tos of testing for years. <BR><BR>We’ve compiled this information and made it easy for you to find all in one place with our easy-to-read report – <EM>Secrets of Direct Marketing Testing</EM>. Secrets of Direct Marketing Testing

Available as a PDF

A guide to the science of direct response testing today, including best practices, power tests, small vs. large test, analyzing results, testing mistakes, new tricks and more.

Direct marketing — regardless of the channel — is that unique combination of art and science. Direct marketing strategists are constantly striving



...

ORDER NOW

Available as a PDF<BR><BR>Your everything-you-need-to-know guide to personalized URLs, including: <B>Best Practices </B>on why they work, campaign strategy, multichannel creative, analytics, and <B>10 Case Studies.<BR></B><BR>A New Best Practices and Case Studies report from DirectMarketingIQ.<BR> <BR>Do you want a higher response rate? Do you want to make a bigger profit? Do you want to engage your customers and continue the conversation? Then ... you need to know about PURLs and how they can achieve all the above and more! <BR><BR>With <EM>PURLs for Profit </EM>you'll have your personal roadmap that will show you how to successfully implement and profit from PURLs. This definitive special report takes you step-by-step on how to integrate PURLs into your marketing mix — email, direct mail, landing pages and social media — for an enhanced user experience so that prospects can make more informed purchasing decisions faster. <BR><BR>Here are just a few of the important takeaways you'll learn:<BR>
<UL>
<LI>Why PURLs work 
<LI>How PURLs connect the dots between direct mail, email, social media and the web 
<LI>What you should test and why 
<LI>What campaigns benefit most from PURLs 
<LI>How to create a relevant campaign 
<LI>Privacy and PURLs 
<LI>What steps should you take 
<LI>How to measure your ROI 
<LI>Maintain the magic by maximizing the message, the creative and the list! 
<LI>The importance of tracking and continuing the conversation 
<LI>Where social media fits into the mix </LI></UL>
<P>In addition, you'll see actual case studies where PURLs have made a big difference in a variety of marketing efforts. <BR><BR>Here's a list of the types of companies and organizations that are featured in this informative special report: </P>
<UL>
<LI>Financial Services 
<LI>Higher Education 
<LI>Publishing 
<LI>Nonprofit 
<LI>Retail 
<LI>Technology 
<LI>Seminar/Conference 
<LI>Quick-Service Restaurant</LI></UL>
<P>Download your copy of <EM>PURLs for Profit</EM> today!</P> PURLs for Profit

Available as a PDF

Your everything-you-need-to-know guide to personalized URLs, including: Best Practices on why they work, campaign strategy, multichannel creative, analytics, and 10 Case Studies.

A New Best Practices and Case Studies report from DirectMarketingIQ.

Do you want a higher response rate? Do you want to make a bigger profit? Do you





...

ORDER NOW

 

MORE ON EMAIL >>

FROM THE BOOKSTORE

Available as a PDF.<BR> <BR>A guide to prospecting, lead generation, building an Opt-in database, tracking, social media integration, deliverability, mining content and balanced creative. While email marketing has reached maturity, there’s still plenty of life in this channel — if used wisely. <BR><BR>That’s the focus of this new guide to email marketing, with articles devoted to best practices for prospecting; continuing to build and refresh your opt-in file; how social and email work together; generating relevant content; keeping your messages safe from spam filters and junk-mail folders; and more. <BR><BR>Are you searching for ways to create stronger email marketing campaigns? <BR><BR>The DirectMarketingIQ and Target Marketing editorial teams have been researching, writing and collecting expert advice from industry leaders about how to create top-notch email marketing campaigns for years. <BR><BR>We’ve compiled this information and made it easy for you to find all in one place, with our easy-to-read report – <EM>Email Marketing That Works (2nd Edition)</EM>. Email Marketing that Works (2nd Edition)

Available as a PDF.

A guide to prospecting, lead generation, building an Opt-in database, tracking, social media integration, deliverability, mining content and balanced creative. While email marketing has reached maturity, there’s still plenty of life in this channel — if used wisely.

That’s the focus of this new guide to email



...

ORDER NOW

Available as a PDF<BR><BR>A guide to the science of direct response testing today, including best practices, power tests, small vs. large test, analyzing results, testing mistakes, new tricks and more.<BR> <BR>Direct marketing — regardless of the channel — is that unique combination of art and science. Direct marketing strategists are constantly striving for better response rates, open rates, conversions, cost-per-order, and life-time value. <BR><BR>And what is the tool that these strategists turn to again and again? That’s right! It’s testing. <BR><BR>In direct marketing, there are plenty of elements to test — from subject lines, premiums, envelope sizes, list selects, pricing, the placement of the shopping cart on the web page ... the choices seem endless. <BR><I><BR>Secrets of Direct Marketing Testing </I>is your personal BRAIN TRUST of testing strategies that you can start to put to use today. <BR><BR>In this guide, you’ll find everything you need to learn — the why, what, when and how-to of testing. From testing structure to basic principles, and from test ideas to mistakes to avoid, you’ll get a crash course in coding, tracking, reading and applying test results. <BR><BR>You’ll learn about: <BR>• Simple copy tests that drive response <BR>• Fine-tuning your offer <BR>• Web and Email testing <BR>• Offer tests <BR>• How to make sure you’re getting reliable results <BR>• Retesting and rolling out your findings <BR>• Plus the Rules that you should test now — or ignore at your own peril! <BR><BR>Are you are searching for ways to raise response, save on your promotion costs, drive down your cost-per-order and extend the lifetime value of your customers? The DirectMarketingIQ and Target Marketing editorial teams have been researching, writing and collecting expert advice from industry leaders about the how-tos of testing for years. <BR><BR>We’ve compiled this information and made it easy for you to find all in one place with our easy-to-read report – <EM>Secrets of Direct Marketing Testing</EM>. Secrets of Direct Marketing Testing

Available as a PDF

A guide to the science of direct response testing today, including best practices, power tests, small vs. large test, analyzing results, testing mistakes, new tricks and more.

Direct marketing — regardless of the channel — is that unique combination of art and science. Direct marketing strategists are constantly striving



...

ORDER NOW

 

COMMENTS

Click here to leave a comment...
Comment *
Most Recent Comments:
Andrew Wilson - Posted on April 22, 2010
@Brian Allen there is just so much wrong with your post. Get yourself a good US consultant to show you how to make it work.
Dan Croxen-John - Posted on April 22, 2010
Hi Pat,

Thanks for the effort in putting together some key points that explain the enduring usage of direct mail.

Although I run a web analytics consultancy, I come from a mail order backgroup and am always interested in this direct mail vs online communication debate.

However, although I don't agree with Brian's sentiment, I do think that cost is an important issue with direct mail. We work with mail order companies that have identified when they can afford to send a catalogue or a piece of DM to a low-responding segment. Many of our clients have used email to still communicate with those segments and re-activate these lapsed customers profitably. So in my view, it's not a case of replacing one with the other, but using DM and email based on CPA thresholds.

But ultimately, as direct marketers we continue to obsess on ROI - and rightly so. This means if your DM campaign appears not to be working then it is because either it really isn't working or you have failed to build in a tracking mechanism.

Having said that one of our clients successfully uses locally-based DM and email campaigns, and I think we forget the value of 'local targeting' at our peril.

Keep up the good work

Dan Croxen-John
Applied Web Analytics



Bruce Colthart (@bccreative) - Posted on April 19, 2010
Thanks for the nicely-articulated list. Too often the "print versus online" argument focuses on publishing only and its sentimental attachments. Your list is exactly the message I want to impress upon my clients – print is a medium; understand it and take advantage of its unique properties as part of your overall marketing strategy.
Blase Ciabaton - Posted on April 11, 2010
Thanks so much for sharing this post, Pat! I've been a direct mail professional for the last 6 years, and not a week goes by where I don' t get first-hand testimonials from clients who switched to an all e-mail communication platform with results similar to what you describe in this post.

Regarding Brian's comment, there is no shortage of direct mail horror stories. Poorly executed campaigns will generate poor results. Mailing to existing clients, like the example given in your post, is a cost-effective & proven strategy for many businesses. For prospect mailings, nothing is more important than targeting the correct list. I recently wrote a blog post titled "Help, Why Did My Last Direct Mail Campaign Fail?" http://bit.ly/biJd4p, which may be of interest to readers of this post.

Finally, I also embrace the concept of using multiple channels when marketing. Even though direct mail is my business, I also have a blog and a Twitter account, and I'm active with both face to face marketing and other forms of social marketing. Thanks again! Blase
Rick Graf - Posted on April 09, 2010
I enjoyed your article, "Direct Mail: Dead or Dead On?"

I wish I had it 4 years ago to present to a former client who dropped direct mail from his marketing to reply only on email.

I've always felt that an independent voice helps to support a point of view, because my clients sometimes see what I say as somewhat self-serving.

Thanks again. Please know that I will be sending it to the next client who wants to replace direct mail with only email marketing.

Rick Graf
Brian Allen - Posted on April 08, 2010
Your article highlights exactly the opposite of what you're trying to promote.

Direct mail marketing for new prospects is completely worthless.

We mailed for over 500 companies last year,400 of whom were mailing to prospects and less than 1 out of 30 ever repeated with us.

Make no mistake about it; direct mailers are dinosaurs with no possible way to justify the cost.
Click here to view archived comments...
Archived Comments:
Andrew Wilson - Posted on April 22, 2010
@Brian Allen there is just so much wrong with your post. Get yourself a good US consultant to show you how to make it work.
Dan Croxen-John - Posted on April 22, 2010
Hi Pat,

Thanks for the effort in putting together some key points that explain the enduring usage of direct mail.

Although I run a web analytics consultancy, I come from a mail order backgroup and am always interested in this direct mail vs online communication debate.

However, although I don't agree with Brian's sentiment, I do think that cost is an important issue with direct mail. We work with mail order companies that have identified when they can afford to send a catalogue or a piece of DM to a low-responding segment. Many of our clients have used email to still communicate with those segments and re-activate these lapsed customers profitably. So in my view, it's not a case of replacing one with the other, but using DM and email based on CPA thresholds.

But ultimately, as direct marketers we continue to obsess on ROI - and rightly so. This means if your DM campaign appears not to be working then it is because either it really isn't working or you have failed to build in a tracking mechanism.

Having said that one of our clients successfully uses locally-based DM and email campaigns, and I think we forget the value of 'local targeting' at our peril.

Keep up the good work

Dan Croxen-John
Applied Web Analytics



Bruce Colthart (@bccreative) - Posted on April 19, 2010
Thanks for the nicely-articulated list. Too often the "print versus online" argument focuses on publishing only and its sentimental attachments. Your list is exactly the message I want to impress upon my clients – print is a medium; understand it and take advantage of its unique properties as part of your overall marketing strategy.
Blase Ciabaton - Posted on April 11, 2010
Thanks so much for sharing this post, Pat! I've been a direct mail professional for the last 6 years, and not a week goes by where I don' t get first-hand testimonials from clients who switched to an all e-mail communication platform with results similar to what you describe in this post.

Regarding Brian's comment, there is no shortage of direct mail horror stories. Poorly executed campaigns will generate poor results. Mailing to existing clients, like the example given in your post, is a cost-effective & proven strategy for many businesses. For prospect mailings, nothing is more important than targeting the correct list. I recently wrote a blog post titled "Help, Why Did My Last Direct Mail Campaign Fail?" http://bit.ly/biJd4p, which may be of interest to readers of this post.

Finally, I also embrace the concept of using multiple channels when marketing. Even though direct mail is my business, I also have a blog and a Twitter account, and I'm active with both face to face marketing and other forms of social marketing. Thanks again! Blase
Rick Graf - Posted on April 09, 2010
I enjoyed your article, "Direct Mail: Dead or Dead On?"

I wish I had it 4 years ago to present to a former client who dropped direct mail from his marketing to reply only on email.

I've always felt that an independent voice helps to support a point of view, because my clients sometimes see what I say as somewhat self-serving.

Thanks again. Please know that I will be sending it to the next client who wants to replace direct mail with only email marketing.

Rick Graf
Brian Allen - Posted on April 08, 2010
Your article highlights exactly the opposite of what you're trying to promote.

Direct mail marketing for new prospects is completely worthless.

We mailed for over 500 companies last year,400 of whom were mailing to prospects and less than 1 out of 30 ever repeated with us.

Make no mistake about it; direct mailers are dinosaurs with no possible way to justify the cost.